Tech Hiring Case Study: How an Indianapolis Shop Sorts Applicants
Jo Rosenberger
“Everybody’s an A Tech Till You Get Them Here”
Written by: Jo Rosenberger Last Revision: October 20, 2026
This tech hiring case study looks at how Rightway Automotive, a family-owned shop in Indianapolis, uses the Promotive platform to review applicants and hire on its own schedule. For one technician opening, Rightway got 15 applicants, sorted out the 9 that weren’t a fit, and made a hire.
At a glance
- Shop: Rightway Automotive, 411 S. Shortridge Road, Indianapolis, IN
- Owners: Sean Ritzi and Mike Kitterman, serving Indianapolis since 2000
- Hiring for: technician
- Results so far: 15 applicants, 1 hire, 9 screened out as not a fit (Promotive portal, as of Oct 20, 2026)
Who is Rightway Automotive?
Sean and Mike started out in dealerships. They were doing so much side work that they went out on their own, first in a rented garage and then in the building on Shortridge Road they’ve run since 2000. “We started out just me and him,” Sean says. Sean grew up less than five miles from the shop.

Today Rightway is a full team: technicians, a service manager, a service advisor and a bookkeeper. The shop’s slogan is “Repairs Done Right The First Time,” and the team sticks around. Sean and Mike have each been at the shop for 23 years. Technician Jeff Loy has been there 21, and Kaye Branham has kept the books for more than 8. Kaye’s take: the owners are “very fair to customers and employees.”
Rightway services American, European and import vehicles. The work includes brakes, steering and suspension, cooling systems, diagnostics and oil changes, and customers get digital vehicle inspections sent by text or email. The shop has ASE-certified techs and is part of the Tech-Net Auto Repair Center network, which comes with a nationwide warranty. Customers also get a loaner vehicle, a local shuttle and after-hours drop-off. Visit Rightway Automotive →
Why is tech hiring harder now?
“It’s not like back in the day, when you had a drawer full of applicants and picked which one to hire,” Sean says. Applicants still come in, but many go quiet. “You call, they don’t call you back. You text, they don’t text you back… but they’re out there looking for jobs.” Ghosting is a real issue shops face, read more about it Why Shops Lose Techs Before The Interview→
What changed in Rightway’s technician hiring?
In the Promotive portal, Sean sees everyone who applied to his job in one list, and he works it when it suits him. “I can go in there and look up resumes and phone numbers, make phone calls at my will, not dependent on somebody else to do that for me, and set up interviews. It’s huge.”
How does Rightway Automotive handle tech hiring in the portal?
- Reviews new applicants as they arrive: he reads the resume and, when completed, the prescreen summary from Paige, Promotive’s AI recruiter.
- Sorts quickly: 9 of his 15 applicants went straight to “Not a fit,” so his time goes to the quality applicants.
- Adds quick notes like “messaged and texted, no response,” so he knows where each applicant stands when he comes back.
- Interviews his top picks first: “I want to be able to pull in the ones that I’m really interested in. If those don’t work out, then I’ll go to the alternatives from there.”
Why does knowing the tech before the call matter?
“Everybody’s an A tech till you get them here,” Sean says. Reading an applicant’s experience up front helps him see where they really stand, and whether a solid B tech could be the right hire. “The more you know about that person, the better off you are.”
What’s the support from Promotive like?
Sean has mainly worked with Stacy Black at Promotive. “She’s been great. Always responsive, getting back to us pretty quick.”
Hiring your next tech? Talk to us about how the Promotive portal can work for your shop.
Rightway Automotive hires technicians through the Promotive portal, where co-owner Sean Ritzi reviews every applicant to his job in one list. He reads each resume, sets aside the ones that aren’t a fit and contacts his top picks on his own schedule. For one technician opening, he got 15 applicants and made a hire.
Yes. Shop owners can review and contact applicants themselves in the Promotive portal. You see every applicant for your jobs in one list, read their resume and prescreen summary, and mark each one Shortlisted, Maybe or Not a fit. You can also add notes and track follow-ups.
A prescreen summary is the written result of a call between an applicant and Paige, Promotive’s AI recruiter. It covers availability, years of experience, A/B/C skill level, makes worked on, daily duties, and diagnostic and electrical skills. You know who you’re talking to before you pick up the phone.
When an applicant stops responding, note the attempt and keep your next-best candidate in line instead of waiting. Sean logs messages like “texted, no response” so he knows where each applicant stands, then moves on to his alternatives. Fast follow-up helps too: most drop-off happens before the interview.
If a shop isn’t finding the technician it needs, we can discuss upgrading to Recruit. Promotive’s team handles sourcing, screening and review, and the shop follows progress in the same portal. Learn more about Promotive’s Hiring Support
How to Fill Hard-to-Fill Technician Roles (When Nobody’s Applying)
Last updated: November 16, 2026 · By Jo Rosenberger Hard-to-fill technician roles, like A techs, diagnostic and electrical techs, diesel techs and experienced service advisors, stay open because most qualified people already have jobs and aren’t applying. To fill them, make your offer competitive for your market, go to the techs who aren’t looking, move…
Automotive Recruiting Agency vs Job Boards: Which Fills Your Bay Faster?
Last updated: November 10, 2026 · By Jo Rosenberger An automotive recruiting agency usually fills a technician job faster than a job board when the role is hard to fill or you don’t have time to chase applicants. A job board is cheaper and faster to start, but you do the sorting, calling and screening…
The Automotive Technician Hiring Process: 10 Steps to Hire Good Techs in 2026
Last updated: November 20, 2026 · By Jo Rosenberger A good automotive technician hiring process is the same 10 steps, run the same way every time. Define the role, build a scorecard, source from several channels and reply to applicants the same day. Then prescreen, interview, check skills, make a written offer, onboard for 90…
Technician Hiring for Multi-Location Repair Shops
One hiring pipeline for every shop you run. Open jobs by location, get a prescreen summary on every applicant before you call, and let our recruiters work the pipeline while you run your shops. Last updated: October 27, 2026 Technician hiring for multi-location shops works best when every store hires the same way. That means…
How to Choose an Automotive Recruitment Service for Multi-Location Shops (2026)
Last updated: October 27, 2026 · Promotive wrote this guide and is one of the options listed. To choose an automotive recruitment service for a multi-location shop, start with two questions: who finds and screens your techs, and can you see hiring by location? Recruiters source and screen for you. Hiring software gives your managers…
Why Auto Shops Lose Technicians (and What Hiring Alone Won’t Fix)
Last updated: October 27, 2026 · Auto shops lose technicians mostly for reasons inside the shop: an unpredictable flat-rate board, a bad work mix, a service manager techs don’t trust, missing equipment, no training path and schedules that eat Saturdays. Recruiting adds a second layer: the wrong skill level, slow hiring, an oversold job and…